Get our FREE coffee cheat sheet and get your coffee brew perfect every time.
When you sign up to our newsletter

    By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from Above Average Coffee. We'll respect your privacy and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    The 11 Best Coffee Percolators

    by Scott Deans | Last Updated: August 22, 2022

    This site participates in various affiliate programs including Amazon’s. Purchases made via our links may result in commission at no additional cost to you.

    Want a piping hot cup of coffee with a strong, rich taste? Then a percolator may be the brew method for you. Percolators are as simple to use as a regular drip coffee maker. But you get a much stronger coffee taste when the cycle is done.

    Compared to other coffee machines, the percolator is also relatively inexpensive. You can find a variety of options for under $100.

    An electric percolator does most of the work for you and can keep coffee piping hot for hours. Or, if you want a plug-free version, you can choose a stovetop percolator.

    With a percolator, you’ll hear the comforting gurgle of coffee brewing and get an extra-hot cup of coffee when the brew cycle is done!

    We’ve chosen 11 of the best coffee percolators on today’s market. We’ll share the pros and cons of each so you can find the right fit for you.

    Are you feeling perky? Let’s dive in…

    The Top 6 Best Coffee Percolators

    1. Top Choice – Cuisinart PRC-12 Classic 12-Cup Stainless-Steel Coffee Percolator Black/Stainless

    Cuisinart Percolator

    Brand: Cuisinart

    Pros

    • 4-12 cups of coffee
    • Stainless steel percolator
    • Easy pour spout
    • Detachable cord
    • Ready indicator light

    Cons

    • Plastic knob

    Price & Reviews

    The Cuisinart PRC-12 is an electric percolator with a sleek look. This stainless steel coffee pot can brew a small batch of coffee for one or two, or up to 12 cups for more coffee drinkers. The hot water cycles through the grounds to give you a rich cup of hot coffee. You can watch the water change to coffee in the clear knob on top. It’s magical!

    With the stay-cool base, you don’t have to worry about heat damaging your countertop.

    The indicator light comes on to alert you when the cycle is done. Pour up a cup of coffee and enjoy the rich flavor of perked coffee. When it’s time to clean the machine, detach the cord and store it away until the next use.

    2. Runner Up – Hamilton Beach 12 Cup Electric Percolator Coffee Maker Stainless Steel Quick Brew (40616)

    2 Hamilton Beach Percolator

    Brand: Hamilton Beach

    Pros

    • 2-12 cups of coffee
    • Keep warm function
    • Brews a cup a minute
    • Stainless steel pot, brew basket, and stem
    • Can brew hot water for tea or instant cocoa
    • Removable cord
    • Indicator light
    • Some dishwasher-safe parts

    Cons

    • No clear knob to watch the brew cycle

    Price & Reviews

    The Hamilton Beach electric percolator is made from high-quality stainless steel. Even the permanent filter and stem are stainless steel (not aluminum) which sets this pot apart from many others.

    This electric coffee percolator automatically brews up to 12 cups of coffee for your morning cuppa. It features a cool-touch handle, a removable cord, and an easy pour spout. If you are in the mood for tea, instant oatmeal, or hot cocoa, this attractive percolator can also come in handy. Heat hot water in the pot and pour it over a tea bag, hot cereal, or hot cocoa powder.

    After brewing up coffee at one cup per minute, the coffee maker lights up to let you know when your coffee is done. Then, it keeps the coffee hot without burning your brew. When it comes time to clean up, you can pop the inside stem and brew basket into the dishwasher.

    One drawback is that the top knob is not see-through, so you can’t keep an eye on your coffee while it brews. Still, this detail doesn’t have to be a deal-breaker.

    3. Budget Option – Moss & Stone Electric Coffee Percolator

    Moss and Stone Percolator

    Brand: Moss and Stone

    Pros

    • 2-10 cups of coffee
    • Copper exterior/Stainless steel interior
    • Cool touch handle
    • 1-year warranty
    • Glass knob

    Cons

    • Larger holes in the filter basket

    Price & Reviews

    The Moss and Stone Electric Coffee Percolator makes 2 to 10 cups of delicious, rich-tasting coffee. This attractive design boasts a copper body and stainless steel interior. Even the permanent filter basket and stem are stainless steel.

    This pot can brew up to 10 cups of coffee at once. You can keep an eye on your coffee’s progress through the glass knob, while you listen to the gentle perking of the pot.

    This elegant and durable coffee pot also features a cool-touch handle, and an indicator light to let you know your coffee is made. Its automatic keep-warm function keeps your coffee toasty warm long after the brew cycle is finished.

    Moss and Stone backs its quality percolator with a one-year warranty. At under $50, this is a pretty sweet deal.

    4. Traditional Option – Presto 02811 12-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

    Presto Percolator

    Brand: Presto

    Pros

    • 2-12 cups of coffee
    • No spill spout
    • Durable stainless steel construction
    • Stainless steel filter basket and perk tube
    • Read-to-serve indicator light
    • Keep-warm function

    Cons

    • Plastic knob

    Price & Reviews

    The Presto Stainless Steel Coffee Maker has a large fan base. This percolator has over 16,000 reviews and keeps a good reputation with 4.6 stars on Amazon. This machine can make up to 12 cups of coffee and lets you know when it is ready with an indicator light.

    You can leave it plugged in so the coffee stays warm for longer. Or, you can remove the electric cord completely and serve coffee straight out of the carafe. The easy-pour spout lets you fill up a favorite mug without spilling drops onto your tablecloth.

    With its sleek design, this percolator can add an element of elegance to any table.

    5. Best For Smaller Batches – Spectrum Brands Farberware 8-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel FCP280 Black

    Spectrum Brands Farberware 8-Cup Percolator

    Brand: Farberware

    Pros

    • 1-8 cup pot
    • Compact size
    • Stainless steel
    • Automatic keep-warm function

    Cons

    • No indicator light
    • Short cord

    Price & Reviews

    This stainless steel Farberware pot brews 1 to 8 cups of coffee and is slightly smaller than other models. Instead of the elegant, elongated look, this percolator is short and stout with a wide, quick-pour spout.

    You can leave it plugged in to keep your coffee warm. However, this model does not have an indicator light to signal that is still plugged in. This means it is up to you to remember to unplug this little guy before you head out the door.

    The Farberware can brew at a rate of one cup per minute. It makes you a deliciously hot cup of coffee to start your morning out on the right foot.

    6. Best for a Crowd – Hamilton Beach Commercial Stainless Steel Coffee Urn, 60 Cup Capacity

    Hamilton Beach Commercial Stainless Steel Coffee Urn

    Brand: Hamilton Beach

    Pros

    • Serves a large crowd
    • Keeps coffee warm at an optimal temperature
    • Cup trip spout
    • Polished stainless steel exterior
    • Stainless steel interior
    • Ready indicator light
    • Water/coffee level window
    • Brews one cup per minute
    • Glass knob

    Cons

    • Can take one hour to brew at full capacity

    Price & Reviews

    This large percolator is perfect for a work breakroom, catering, or large gatherings. It can hold up to 60 cups of coffee and has a cup trip spout so you can fill up a mug one-handed. You can also prop up the dispenser handle to fill a larger carafe. Both the inside and outside of this percolator are stainless steel so it is made to resist wear and tear.

    The vertical window into the pot lets you know if coffee is running low. And the glass knob lets you know where you are in the brew cycle. This pot can brew at one cup per minute, which means you need to set it up an hour in advance if you plan on using it at full capacity.

    The Hamilton Beach Commercial Stainless Steel Coffee Urn can brew up a tasty brew for all your friends.

    A Buyer’s Guide to Finding the Best Coffee Percolator

    Are you a coffee lover in search of the perfect cup of coffee? A percolator may be your cup of tea …er coffee. As you narrow down the list of similar yet different percolators, here are a few things to consider.

    This checklist can help you find the right coffee maker for you!

    The Material of Your Pot

    You can also choose what material you want your percolator coffee pot to be. The most common choices are stainless steel, enamelware, and glass.

    Stainless steel percolators are some of the most common. These pots are durable and give you a clean flavor. However, often, the filter basket and stem on the inside are made of aluminum. If you want a percolator that is stainless all the way, be sure to read the fine print when buying your pot.

    Enamelware pots have a nice old-fashioned look. They are usually made of metal, aluminum, or cast iron and covered in a porcelain coating. These pots are lightweight, easy to clean, and an inexpensive option. It can be a great option for going camping.

    Glass stovetop percolators allow the clean coffee taste to come through. They are also fascinating to watch while the water turns into a dark caramel-colored brew. However, you need to handle these pots with care. Don’t let the water start a rolling boil, or you may end up with a cracked pot on your hands.

    Electric or Stovetop Coffee Maker

    When deciding on the best percolator, you have two main options: electric or stovetop.

    The electric percolator is easy to use. You fill the basket with the right amount of coffee grounds, then start the cycle. Some even have a keep warm function to keep your coffee hot longer after the brew cycle is done. The electric percolator is simple to use, however, you need to be careful when you clean it. The base and cord should not get wet which can make it a bit tricky to clean.

    A stovetop percolator can be a great way to make coffee the old-fashioned way. No need for electricity with this perky pot! However, you need to keep an eye on the time and temperature of your brew. You don’t want your coffee to come out too weak or too strong! Stovetop percolators tend to be easier to wash than the electric version. Some can even be washed in the dishwasher.

    The Knob

    The lid’s knob is usually not a big deal on most coffee brewers. However, with the percolator, even the knob can serve a purpose. Most coffee lovers prefer a see-through glass knob. This gives you a window to the brew, and lets you know when the coffee is ready. Other’s opt for a plastic or resin knob. These cheaper options may or may not be see-through.

    Size

    One big plus of a percolator pot is that it can save you space on your countertop. Most models are compact and easy to store in a kitchen cabinet. Most percolators can brew a small batch or for several coffee drinkers. However, if you need to make coffee for a crowd, you can choose an extra-large electric percolator that brews up to 60 cups.

    An Electric Percolator Pot Pouring Some Cups of Coffee

    FAQs

    Are Percolators and Moka Pots the Same?

    At first glance, percolators and Moka pots seem to brew coffee the same way. For both methods, the filter basket sits at the top and the water underneath. However, the two brewing methods are very different. You should set your grinder to a medium-coarse grind for percolators, while Moka pots need finely ground coffee.

    Similar to an espresso maker, Moka pots use pressure to force water through the grounds once, At the end, the coffee sits in the top basket. But, with a percolator, the water cycles through the grounds. It continues to brew until you remove it from its heat source.

    Is Percolated Coffee Stronger than French Press?

    The French press method is better for showing off the nuances in the flavors of your coffee beans. However, a percolator generally makes a stronger-tasting coffee. Perking coffee is quick and efficient. Cup for cup, its brew time is shorter than a French Press. A percolator can also make a lot of coffee at one time!

    Stovetop Models and Camping Percolators Reviewed

    7. Medelco One All 8-Cup Capacity Stovetop Glass Percolator

    Medelco One All 8-Cup Capacity Stovetop Glass Percolator

    Brand: Medelco

    Pros

    • 8-cup
    • Borosilicate glass pot
    • Cool touch handle
    • Dishwasher safe
    • Trivet for coil electric stoves included
    • Temperature resistant
    • Inexpensive at less than $30

    Cons

    • More fragile than steel pots

    Price & Reviews

    This Medelco stovetop percolator allows you to make a full-bodied brew just like grandma used to do. The Medelco pot is made from heat-resistant borosilicate glass. It comes with a trivet to place under the pot on coil electric stoves. This trivet ensures that the heat distributes evenly under the glass base.

    With this glass coffee pot, you have a clear window into your coffee’s brew cycle. Now, that’s a perk! However, you want to use appropriate heat so your pot doesn’t overheat and break. (No rolling boils!) Low to medium heat is usually best for this unique, old-fashioned brewer.

    8. Farberware 47053 Classic Stainless Steel Yosemite 12-Cup Coffee Percolator 12 Cup Coffee Maker Silver

    Farberware 47053 Classic Stainless Steel Yosemite 12-Cup Coffee Percolator

    Brand: Farberware

    Pros

    • 12 cup pot
    • Dishwasher safe
    • Permanent filter basket
    • Heavy-duty stainless steel
    • Lifetime warranty
    • Clear glass knob

    Cons

    • Glass knob can break in camping wear and tear

    Price & Reviews

    This original 12-Cup Farberware Stovetop Percolator is made out of heavy-duty stainless steel. The permanent filter basket requires no paper filters. This can make your life easier when you are camping out in the wild. It’s less to pack and less mess on a campsite.

    However, this stovetop percolator is not just for the trail! It is also perfect for home use. It is durable, easy to use, and can store away easily when not in use.

    It comes equipped with a see-through glass knob and a cool-touch handle. Unlike the electric models that can’t be submerged, this stovetop percolator is completely dishwasher-safe

    If you run into problems, no worries! Farberware guarantees this stovetop percolator for life.

    9. Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Stovetop Coffee Percolator

    Coleman 12-Cup Stainless Steel Stovetop Coffee Percolator

    Brand: Coleman

    Pros

    • 12-cup capacity
    • Brews up to 12 cups of coffee
    • Stainless steel construction
    • Lightweight and durable for camp life

    Cons

    • The metal handle may become hot to the touch

    Price & Reviews

    The Coleman percolator is made out of stainless steel. It is highly resistant to corrosion and is lightweight so it packs easily. It can brew up to 12 cups of coffee for your camping trips. Or, you can set it up on your kitchen stove for a great cup of morning coffee.

    The Coleman avoids plastic, so you don’t have to worry about plastic melting when you brew over the campfire. However, be careful grabbing that metal handle when you remove the pot from the heat. It may become pretty hot!

    This durable percolator is sure to catch your imagination!

    10. COLETTI Bozeman Camping Coffee Pot

    COLETTI Bozeman Camping Coffee Pot

    Brand: Coletti

    Pros

    • Stainless steel and wood
    • No plastic or aluminum parts
    • Indoor/outdoor use
    • Cup measurement markings
    • Lifetime replacement guarantee
    • Percolator coffee filters included
    • Tempered glass knob

    Cons

    • The lid opens easily so you need to hold it in place as you pour.

    Price & Reviews

    This Coletti Bozeman coffee pot is solidly constructed from stainless steel. The handle is protected with wood so it doesn’t get too hot to handle when you’re hot camping. The cup markings make this percolator easy to set up. Now, you can get your coffee-to-water ratio correct even on a trail! If you don’t enjoy stary grounds floating in your coffee, you can try out a coffee filter that is specifically designed for percolator pots.

    The tempered glass knob is also a nice touch.

    Whether you use it indoors or outdoors, this durable Coletti percolator is simply delightful.

    11. GSI Outdoors Percolator Coffee Pot 12 Cup Enamelware

    GSI Outdoors Percolator Coffee Pot 12 Cup Enamelware

    Brand: GSI Outdoors

    Pros

    • 12-cup capacity
    • Perky enamelware colors
    • Made from heavy-gauge steel coated in enamelware
    • 3-ply construction for even heat distribution
    • Clear resin knob
    • Product lifetime guarantee

    Cons

    • Dropping the pot can cause damage to the enamelware finish.

    Price & Reviews

    For a classic camping look, you can’t beat the GSI Outdoors enamelware percolator. This percolator can brew up to 12 cups and looks fabulous doing it. The knob is resin instead of glass to be more resistant on the trail. The 3-ply construction maintains a consistent heat while you brew up a fresh cuppa. This friendly percolator pot is lightweight and travel-friendly.

    You can make coffee the old-fashioned way while you enjoy the great outdoors.

    Wrap up

    Whether you live in a small space, make coffee on camping trips, or just love the taste of rich, hot coffee at home, a percolator is a great option. A percolator brews coffee at high temperatures by cycling water through coffee grounds. This brewing method gives you a robust and layered coffee flavor that is simply delicious. You can plug in an electric pot, or enjoy the gentle gurgle of coffee perking on the stovetop.

    I hope you enjoyed our tips for finding the best percolators on the market today. Happy Brewing!

    Can you guess what keeps me up at night? You guessed it! Copious amounts of coffee beans. What? I brew them first.