Percolating Deals Just For You: Unveiling Our New Deals Page! Discover New Deals 👉
Or join the coffee revolution, sign up for our newsletter and get access to the hottest coffee deals, exclusive insights, and more!

    By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from Above Average Coffee. We'll respect your privacy and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    by Justin | Last Updated: June 13, 2023

    This site participates in various affiliate programs including Amazon’s. Purchases made via our links may result in commission at no additional cost to you.

    Image description

    Discover the best Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA with our comprehensive guide.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    In the heart of Pennsylvania lies a treasure chest of delightful coffee experiences waiting to be discovered by the discerning palate. Welcome to Lancaster, a town brimming with coffee roasters whose passion for the perfect brew is as rich as the coffee they serve. Today, let us indulge in the inviting aromas and tantalizing flavors of Lancaster County Coffee Roasters, a local favorite with a reputation that precedes it.

    RankingCoffee Roaster NameRating
    1Lancaster County Coffee Roasters4.9
    2Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar4.9
    3Endo Cafe Lancaster4.9
    4Square One Coffee Roasters4.7
    5Passenger Coffee & Tea Showroom4.7
    6Copper Cup4.6
    7New Holland Coffee Co.4.6
    8Mean Cup4.6
    9Cafe One Eight4.6
    10Prince Street Cafe, Lancaster4.5

    In order to provide comprehensive reviews, we have thoroughly analyzed data from the roasters’ website, articles, and social media posts. Further, we can aggregated and summarized, using quote snippets, left by actual customers of the roaster.  Finally, we have included resource reference links to those reviews in a location map if you are looking for more complete information.  We hope you find this valuable in your search for the best coffee roasters in your area.

    Summary review: Lancaster County Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    A potent mix of tradition, innovation, and a whole lot of love for coffee is what makes Lancaster County Coffee Roasters a tour de force in the world of coffee roasting. Being at this coffee haven is akin to witnessing a theatrical performance, where each coffee bean plays its part to perfection. The aroma, as enticing as the opening notes of a symphony, lures you in, and from then on, it’s a coffee lover’s dream come true.

    The ambiance at Lancaster County Coffee Roasters is akin to being nestled inside a well-worn novel – familiar, warm, and full of stories. Each cup of coffee here tells a tale of their unwavering dedication to the craft. With their tantalizing roasts like the smooth and nutty ‘Rainforest Nut Crème’ or the sweet and delightful ‘Cinnamon Hazelnut,’ their flavorful journey has been a hit amongst locals and visitors alike. To order and partake in this journey, visit: Lancaster County Coffee Roasters.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Lancaster County Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    With an impressive average rating of 4.9, Lancaster County Coffee Roasters has brewed its way into the hearts of coffee aficionados far and wide. The reviews, a vibrant tapestry of joy and satisfaction, recount tales of flavorful delights and top-notch customer service. From the robust ‘Dutch Apple Crumbcake’ that seems to have turned everyday coffee drinkers into fervent fans, to the delightful surprises in their flavored decaf options, the reviews point towards a wide array of coffee experiences that never cease to please the palate. Even the occasional blips in service have done little to dampen the enthusiasm of the coffee-loving crowd. So, whether you’re a seasoned coffee connoisseur or a curious newbie, Lancaster County Coffee Roasters promises a cuppa that will leave you yearning for more.

    “` For the META DESCRIPTION: “`less Unearth the best of Lancaster’s coffee scene with our guide to the top coffee roasters. Dive into the world of Lancaster County Coffee Roasters and get ready for an unforgettable brew!

    Summary review: Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar in Lancaster, PA

    Ah, Lancaster, PA, a town where life moves at a leisurely pace and the smell of roasted coffee punctuates the air at regular intervals. It’s no secret that coffee roasting in this town is a bit of a competitive sport, but one name that keeps cropping up is the Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar. Now let me tell you, the first time I walked into Passenger, it felt like I had been teleported to a coffee lover’s paradise, where the only thing stronger than the coffee was the palpable passion for the craft.
    The moment you walk into Passenger Roastery, you’re hit with the intoxicating aroma of freshly roasted coffee that invades your senses in the most pleasant way. It’s like stepping into a coffee-themed amusement park, only instead of roller coasters, there’s a roller roaster. It’s a space that pays homage to the sacred process of coffee making, while still being approachably chic. Ordering coffee here is a delightfully uncomplicated affair. You simply head on over to their website Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar, and choose from their variety of tantalizing roasts. Popular favourites include their light roast, ‘Rwanda Kanzu’, that offers subtle notes of red currant, mandarin orange and brown sugar. For a more balanced cup, customers lean towards the ‘Honduras Las Flores’, a medium roast with notes of dark chocolate, cherry, and toffee. Oh, and their pastries are worth an honorable mention – a warm, buttery croissant paired with a steaming cup of their single origin roast? Perfection.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar in Lancaster, PA

    If Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar were a musician, it would be Mozart, playing to a symphony of clinking coffee mugs, the whooshing of the espresso machine and the hum of the grinder. The reviews for this place read like love letters, penned by besotted coffee enthusiasts, who keep coming back for more. From the exuberant five-star review left by the cappuccino and peach ginger tart lover, it’s evident that Passenger’s quality is unparalleled. It’s not every day that you find a café that offers a traditional Chinese tea ceremony, yet Passenger does just that, coupled with coffee that’s so good it feels like an amnesia-inducing punch to your previous coffee experiences. I must admit, a café that makes a vegan cookie taste ‘amazing’ is nothing short of miraculous. Jay, presumably the heart and soul of the café, is painted as a beacon of warmth and knowledge, proof that good service can elevate a coffee drinking experience. One slightly tepid review mentioned lukewarm water used for tea – a complaint, yes, but one that pales in comparison to the chorus of praise this place has garnered. An average rating of 4.9 only solidifies their reputation as one of the best coffee roasters in town. As for me, I’ll be heading back there to further my coffee education under the skilled tutelage of Jay and his divine vegan cookies.

    Summary review: Endo Cafe Lancaster in Lancaster, PA

    So, you’re wandering around Lancaster, PA, trying to decide where to get your caffeine fix, and you’re faced with the Sophie’s choice of coffee lovers. Allow me to ease your burdens with a little tale about Endo Cafe Lancaster, an unassuming gem with a personality as large as a vintage steamer trunk.
    Nestled somewhere between the old and the new in Lancaster, PA, Endo Cafe Lancaster is like finding a piece of beautifully crafted driftwood along a heavily trodden beach. You could almost mistake it for an art installation with its chic and modern look. From the moment you step into the place, the warm and toasty scent of coffee fills your nostrils, whispering sweet promises of caffeinated bliss in your ear. The staff is not just staff; they are more like well-informed tour guides, eager to walk you through the labyrinth of coffee flavors that Endo has to offer. To bring this experience home, simply go to Endo Cafe Lancaster. Favorite roasts? The ‘Lilac Lover’ gets consistent love, especially during summer, and the ‘Lead Me Alone’ will win you over with its rich, seductive flavor. If Endo Cafe Lancaster were a book, it would be a dog-eared copy of “Me Talk Pretty One Day”, revealing a new laugh-out-loud metaphor or a deep insight with every turn of the page.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Endo Cafe Lancaster in Lancaster, PA

    The reviews for Endo Cafe Lancaster are like a handful of beans thrown into a coffee grinder: They come out consistently positive, with an overall rating of 4.9, demonstrating a commitment to quality that is no less than stunning. Like that childhood best friend who always had the most infectious laughter, the ‘Lilac Lover’ seems to be a crowd favorite, with its unique blend of floral sweetness and robust caffeine kick. And the ‘Lead Me Alone’? More like ‘lead me straight to the altar’, judging by the passionate fanbase that swears by this strong, no-nonsense coffee concoction. From the comfortable seating, the genuinely kind staff, to the creative seasonal drinks, every detail has been carefully considered. And let’s not forget the one feature that sets Endo apart from its peers – the option to pay it forward and offer a coffee treat to a less fortunate soul. With an ambiance that is as inviting as your grandmother’s kitchen, Endo Cafe Lancaster is not just a place to grab a cup of coffee. It is a destination that promises a warm mug, a good laugh, and maybe, just maybe, a story that will stick with you long after you’ve finished your drink.

    Summary review: Square One Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    If you think of Lancaster, PA, the first things that come to mind are Amish country, horse-drawn buggies, and the sweet scent of Shoofly Pie. But, in the heart of this quaint and historic city, there’s a simmering coffee scene that’s brewing up a storm, and Square One Coffee Roasters is a pioneer in this caffeinated revolution.
    At Square One, the brewing magic happens inside a delightful nook in Lancaster’s downtown. Here, the quest for the perfect cup of coffee is not a task but a piece of performance art. I stepped in and was immediately encased in a blanket of warmth emanating from the freshly roasted beans – a smell so potent it could make a night owl switch allegiance. To have a cup of this divine concoction in your hands is as simple as heading over to their website: Square One Coffee Roasters. Now, if you are looking for customer favorites, I recommend the crowd-pleaser, a smooth and velvety house blend that will turn even the most ardent tea lover into a coffee devotee. If you are the adventurous type, then a pour-over with their single-origin beans is a journey worth taking.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Square One Coffee Roasters in Lancaster, PA

    You could say that Square One is to coffee what Picasso was to painting – unconventional, daring, and downright fantastic. But don’t just take my word for it. Let’s embark on a virtual tour of Square One through the lens of its customers. The first stop is a review that screams of praise, “Love this coffee shop!!! High quality coffee, cute cafe treats, friendly service, and amazing ambiance inside…” Well, the three exclamation marks after ‘shop’ do put forth an unspoken rule of the coffee world – a good cafe is like a second home. Next, we have a heartfelt ode to Square One’s “unique drinks”, friendly staff, and relaxing ambiance, marking it as a “Fantastic Lancaster gem!” Ah, who wouldn’t love a place where you can vanish from the world and into the universe of coffee? There’s a review with a slight tinge of disappointment, mostly about the toast rather than the coffee itself. Yet, by the end, they confess, “The latte grew on me and by the end I would have to say it was pretty good.” Ah, the power of good coffee. Then we have praises for a seasonal item – whipped matcha. There’s a confession here, too, “We look forward to coming back!” Well, once bitten by the coffee bug at Square One, it’s hard to stay away. Lastly, we have an accolade for their pour-over coffee, “some of the best coffee I’ve had in a very long time.” There’s also an honorable mention of the spacious ambiance and a recommendation for their single-origin beans. I’d call that a resounding endorsement. It’s no wonder then, that Square One Coffee Roasters sits comfortably with a stellar average rating of 4.7. The multitude of reviews are a testament to the delightful journey that each cup of coffee from Square One offers.

    Summary review: Passenger Coffee & Tea Showroom in Lancaster, PA

    When one thinks of Lancaster, PA, they might first think of rolling Amish farms or quaint, historic downtown streets. But hidden amidst these well-known facets of Lancaster is a treasure just as precious: the Passenger Coffee & Tea Showroom.
    Passenger is to the Lancaster coffee scene what a cherished vinyl record is to a music enthusiast’s collection. It’s a place of pure delight, where the delightful aroma of roasting beans dances through the air and waltzes up to your senses, an inviting overture that suggests: you’re in for something truly special. Ordering from Passenger is as simple as their espresso is rich. Visit their website at Passenger Coffee & Tea Showroom and browse their selection of house roasted beans. A fan favorite is the Ethiopia Sidama Ardi Natural, a roast that strikes a harmonious balance between sweet and savory with notes of strawberry jam and sandalwood.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Passenger Coffee & Tea Showroom in Lancaster, PA

    Think of Passenger as a well-rehearsed string quartet. Every note, every bow stroke, every pause is intentional. Their commitment to their craft is evident, not only in their coffee but also in the echo of their patrons’ reviews. One happy customer says, “Best coffee in central PA, and it’s not close. High quality beans and well trained baristas in a cool shop right in downtown Lancaster. Their pastries are good too, and they pair nicely with a coffee or a tea.” While another customer sings their praises with, “Top notch espresso served by professional staff. Small but classic space right downtown makes for a great experience.” It’s not all standing ovations though, as a couple of patrons have shared some less than perfect experiences. One mentions, “The friendliest service ever! Super nice. Unfortunately my scone pastry seemed like it was a day or two old. Very dry. The cappuccino was pretty but the espresso shot was sour.” Another shares, “We were walking by and stopped for coffee as this place looked so cute!! I got an iced dark chocolate mocha. Unfortunately, the coffee was very bitter and unsweetened.” But every performance has its critics, and with a robust average rating of 4.7, it’s clear that Passenger is still one heck of a show.
    Wrapped in a dreamlike haze, the enigmatic coffee aficionado, Justin, roams the labyrinthine alleyways of the caffeinated world. Amidst the swirling darkness and flickering neon signs, he seeks the elusive, transcendent flavors that lie hidden in the shadowy corners of the coffee bean's soul.