Get our FREE coffee cheat sheet and get your coffee brew perfect every time.
When you sign up to our newsletter

    By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from Above Average Coffee. We'll respect your privacy and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Lafayette, IN

    by Justin | Last Updated: May 17, 2023

    This site participates in various affiliate programs including Amazon’s. Purchases made via our links may result in commission at no additional cost to you.

    Image description

    Discover the best Coffee Roasters in Lafayette, IN with our comprehensive guide.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Lafayette, IN

    RankingCoffee Roaster NameRating
    1The Eleventh House4.9
    2Leaps Coffee Shop4.9
    3Réveille Coffee Bar4.8
    4Sacred Grounds4.8
    5Indie Coffee Roasters4.7
    6Rob’s Java Joz4.7
    7Fuel West4.7
    8Java Jo’z4.7
    9Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette4.6
    10Star City Coffee4.6

    In order to provide comprehensive reviews, we have thoroughly analyzed data from the roasters’ website, articles, and social media posts. Further, we can aggregated and summarized, using quote snippets, left by actual customers of the roaster.  Finally, we have included resource reference links to those reviews in a location map if you are looking for more complete information.  We hope you find this valuable in your search for the best coffee roasters in your area.

    Summary review: The Eleventh House in Lafayette, IN

    Welcome, fellow coffee aficionados, to a journey through the caffeinated realms of Lafayette, IN. Today’s adventure takes us to the bustling yet cozy confines of The Eleventh House, where each cup of coffee is brewed with love and artistry that’ll tickle your taste buds and warm your heart.

    Nestled in the heart of Lafayette, The Eleventh House is a wonderland for coffee enthusiasts and bagel lovers alike. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a symphony of aromas, where coffee beans and freshly baked bagels sing harmoniously in the air.

    Their house coffee drinks are nothing short of legendary – unique concoctions that’ll make you wonder how you ever lived without them. The ham bagel sandwich and coconut lentil soup combo is a crowd favorite, leaving even the most discerning taste buds thoroughly impressed.

    Ordering from The Eleventh House is as easy as pie: The Eleventh House. With just a few clicks, you’ll be on your way to savoring the delightful offerings of this local gem.

    Customer favorites include their seasonal menus, such as the hot cocoa menu that has taken the town by storm. It’s no wonder The Eleventh House is considered the go-to coffee shop in greater Lafayette.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for The Eleventh House in Lafayette, IN

    The Eleventh House has garnered rave reviews from its patrons, with an average rating of 4.8 stars. One reviewer describes the experience as having “great house coffee drinks” and “unique flavors and recipes” that are far superior to any other bagel shop in the area.

    Another customer gushes over the café’s artsy ambience, calling it “one of the coolest cafés I’ve been to!” They particularly enjoyed the bagels and cold coffee, along with the occasional “cool lunch menus” and “nice outdoor sitting.”

    The Eleventh House also earns praise for being the “best drinks in town” and having “plenty of space to work.” Their seasonal menus, such as the hot cocoa offerings, have garnered a loyal following, making it a must-visit destination for coffee lovers.

    One visitor, who ordered an iced pour-over, claims it’s “one of the best” they’ve had in the USA. They even made a special trip from DC to Chicago just to taste the magic for themselves.

    While the avocado bagel receives high marks, one reviewer notes that the service can be slow, taking over 40 minutes to prepare. They also mention a lack of charging ports for laptops, which might be a concern for those planning to study or work there.

    All in all, The Eleventh House is a beloved coffee haven in Lafayette, IN, offering a delightful combination of unique coffee drinks, delicious bagels, and an inviting atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.

    Summary review: Leaps Coffee Shop in Lafayette, IN

    As a local connoisseur, I’ve ventured far and wide to find the best coffee roasters in Lafayette, IN. Leaps Coffee Shop is the latest addition to my list of top contenders. Located inside the Purdue Union, this quaint coffee haven offers a refreshing blend of warm hospitality and an invigorating caffeine fix.

    Like a much-needed respite amidst the bustling campus, Leaps Coffee Shop tempts passersby with the irresistible aroma of freshly roasted coffee. With a selection of delectable pastries and sandwiches to complement their brews, it’s no wonder students and faculty alike flock to this cozy spot.

    To order from Leaps Coffee Shop, visit their website at Leaps Coffee Shop. Customer favorites include their house blend and single-origin offerings, but don’t be shy to explore their seasonal specialties.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Leaps Coffee Shop in Lafayette, IN

    If you’re searching for a coffee shop that captures the essence of a warm hug on a cold day, look no further than Leaps Coffee Shop. Reviewers rave about the friendly staff, delicious coffee, and delightful atmosphere.

    One satisfied customer gushed about their recent visit, saying, “I love coming here! Employees Elyse, Nadia, and Miguel made my experience so pleasant and awesome! They are seriously so heartwarming and make my morning all the time!” With a 5-star rating, it’s clear that Leaps Coffee Shop has not only won the hearts of coffee lovers but has also become a staple in the Purdue Union community.

    Another reviewer, who awarded the coffee shop a solid 4 stars, highlighted their above-average coffee and delicious cinnamon roll, although they wished for more seating options.

    Recent visitors also praised the friendliness and helpfulness of staff members Nadia and Miguel, who made their coffee experience even more enjoyable.

    In summary, Leaps Coffee Shop has proven itself as a worthy addition to Lafayette’s coffee scene. With a dedicated following of satisfied customers, it’s evident that this little gem has carved out a special place in the hearts of coffee enthusiasts.

    Summary review: Réveille Coffee Bar in Lafayette, IN

    As you venture through the charming streets of Lafayette, IN, it’s impossible to resist the siren song of Réveille Coffee Bar. Much like a masterful orchestra conductor, Réveille has a flair for harmoniously blending rich flavors and captivating the hearts of coffee aficionados.

    Nestled in a quaint corner of Lafayette, Réveille Coffee Bar is a caffeinated oasis, where you can indulge in the symphony of flavors that make up their delightful offerings. The baristas, skilled maestros in their craft, compose coffee masterpieces that are music to your taste buds.

    To experience the magic of Réveille Coffee Bar, simply head over to their website: Réveille Coffee Bar. As for customer favorites, the Magic Bowl and iced white mocha take center stage, enchanting both regulars and newcomers alike with their delightful notes.

    If Réveille Coffee Bar were a work of art, it would be…

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Réveille Coffee Bar in Lafayette, IN

    Picture a cozy café, where the scent of freshly brewed coffee dances in the air like an elegant waltz. Réveille Coffee Bar is that enchanting haven, where each sip of coffee tells a story of passion and dedication.

    The reviews sing the praises of Réveille’s charming atmosphere, with one reviewer describing it as “quiet, private and historically pleasant.” Another customer rejoices in the coffee’s deep flavor and lack of bitterness, while yet another highlights the delicious Magic Bowl and iced white mocha as standout offerings.

    However, no coffee bar is without its minor flaws. One reviewer notes that the staff could be more warm and inviting, but acknowledges that this may have been an off day. Despite this, the overall consensus paints a picture of a delightful coffee bar with exceptional drinks and an inviting ambiance.

    With an average rating of 4.4, Réveille Coffee Bar has certainly struck a chord with its customers, leaving them with lasting memories of delightful coffee experiences and a yearning to return for more.

    Summary review: Sacred Grounds in Lafayette, IN

    Sacred Grounds, a haven for coffee enthusiasts, stands as a beacon of warmth and comfort in the heart of Lafayette, IN. Brimming with character and charm, this coffee roastery ensures a delightful experience to those who venture into its cozy embrace.

    As you enter Sacred Grounds, you’re greeted by smiling faces, an atmosphere that invites you to linger, and the enticing aroma of freshly roasted coffee beans. Their menu offers an array of coffee and food options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. You can order your favorite brews and food online through their website: Sacred Grounds. Among the customer favorites are the Ethiopian pour-over and the indulgent Sacred Hippie.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Sacred Grounds in Lafayette, IN

    Let us paint you a picture of Sacred Grounds through the eyes of its patrons. With a stellar average rating of 5, this coffee roastery has garnered glowing reviews from customers who have had the pleasure of experiencing its offerings.

    One reviewer described Sacred Grounds as a “cozy coffee shop,” praising the “beautiful space with smiling faces and good coffee and food offerings.” Another satisfied customer emphasized the “extremely friendly and kind” staff and the “decent” food options.

    A different reviewer shared the delightful experience of trying the Ethiopian pour-over recommended by the owner, as well as the Sacred Hippie, which they likened to “dessert in a cup.” This same customer also enjoyed the breakfast offerings, which included hash browns, eggs, sausage gravy, and bacon.

    The atmosphere at Sacred Grounds is highly praised, with one review highlighting the “impeccable” space, “good indoor lighting,” and “super friendly” staff. Lastly, another reviewer called it the “best coffee house ever in the whole world,” praising the food, the people, and the building itself.

    From the heartwarming reviews, it is evident that Sacred Grounds stands as a beloved coffee roastery in Lafayette, IN, offering exceptional coffee, delicious food, and a welcoming atmosphere.

    Summary review: Indie Coffee Roasters in Lafayette, IN

    There are moments in life when we stumble upon an unassuming treasure, a hidden gem that brings a spark of joy to our daily routine. For coffee enthusiasts in Lafayette, IN, Indie Coffee Roasters is one such treasure, a haven where the fine art of coffee roasting meets the charm of a cozy neighborhood café.

    Located just a stone’s throw away from campus, Indie Coffee Roasters invites you into a world of exquisite coffee experiences. The modern, yet welcoming interior sets the stage for an intimate rendezvous with the finest lattes in town, as one reviewer declares.

    Ordering is a breeze, simply visit Indie Coffee Roasters to indulge in your favorite brew. Customer favorites include their velvety lattes and their seasonal coffees, each a testament to the roaster’s dedication to quality and flavor.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Indie Coffee Roasters in Lafayette, IN

    If coffee shops were characters in a David Sedaris story, Indie Coffee Roasters would be that quirky, lovable friend who always has the perfect anecdote to brighten your day. The reviews for this delightful café are a chorus of praise, singing the virtues of their exceptional coffee and friendly service.

    One reviewer, entranced by the allure of their lattes, claims to have visited the café three times since its opening and wholeheartedly recommends it to fellow latte lovers. Another customer shares their appreciation for the quality espresso and tea selection, adding that the open bar layout and floor-to-ceiling windows make it an ideal spot for studying or casual conversation.

    While one reviewer wishes for mugs with handles to accommodate their sensitive hands, they acknowledge that the coffee is “really REALLY good.” Another patron describes the café as having “fabulous” morning light and looks forward to trying the food on their next visit.

    With an average rating of 4.8, Indie Coffee Roasters has quickly established itself as a favorite among coffee aficionados in Lafayette, IN. Its dedication to crafting exceptional coffee, coupled with its warm and inviting atmosphere, make it a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a truly memorable coffee experience.

    Summary review: Rob’s Java Joz in Lafayette, IN

    The world of coffee in Lafayette, IN, is as exciting and diverse as a treasure trove of rare and fascinating trinkets. Rob’s Java Joz is like the curious little antique shop you stumble upon, only to find a delightful coffee roaster tucked inside.

    Rob’s Java Joz offers a cozy escape from the mundane, with its aroma of roasting beans inviting you in like a gentle hug from an old friend. It’s a place where you can expect a cup of coffee that will warm your heart and tickle your taste buds.

    To order your favorite roast from Rob’s Java Joz, simply visit their website: Rob’s Java Joz. Their signature roasts, like the dark and bold “Night Owl” and the smooth, medium-bodied “Morning Magic,” are crowd favorites.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Rob’s Java Joz in Lafayette, IN

    As we dive into the reviews for Rob’s Java Joz, it’s clear that this quaint coffee roaster has charmed the hearts of its customers with its delightful brews and warm atmosphere.

    One reviewer shares the story of their heavenly coffee, but with a word of caution: “No complaints about the coffee, but beware: even when secured tightly, the lid LEAKS! If you aren’t careful you may end up with coffee dripping all over your car.” Another satisfied customer raves about the comforting nature of the beverages, saying, “Java Joes has been a place of comfort for me. The coffee and tea bring such warmth to my day whether good or bad I know one sip of these outstanding beverages will bring me such joy.”

    Overall, the experiences at Rob’s Java Joz seem to be positive, with one reviewer mentioning their friendly staff and delicious drinks, though they encountered some issues when trying to call the shop. Despite these minor setbacks, the reviewer still recommends the place: “I’ve always had a great experience here, and I definitely recommend everyone new to the area to check either location out. Their chai with soy is my favorite!”

    With an occasional hiccup or two, like a higher price point mentioned by one reviewer, Rob’s Java Joz still shines through as a beloved local coffee roaster. The general consensus among the reviews is that Rob’s Java Joz serves up a quality cup of coffee that’s well worth a visit.

    Summary review: Fuel West in Lafayette, IN

    Picture a cozy, unassuming nook of caffeine-infused happiness nestled near Purdue University. That’s Fuel West, a coffee roaster and café that’s quickly making a name for itself in Lafayette, IN. With an array of delectable house drinks and scrumptious bites, Fuel West is a treasure trove for coffee aficionados and casual sippers alike.

    Located just across the street from the Electrical Engineering building, Fuel West is a beacon of warmth and comfort for students and faculty. Their Hot Chocolate – complete with cream and marshmallows – is a fan favorite, and their Zucchini Bread with melted butter is the ultimate afternoon pick-me-up. And let’s not overlook their vegetarian-friendly menu, which includes a delightful vegetarian chili.

    You can order from Fuel West by visiting their website here: Fuel West. Customer favorites include the spicy Fuel Jacket and the visually stunning teas.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Fuel West in Lafayette, IN

    With an average rating of 4.8 stars, it’s evident that Fuel West has managed to strike the right chord with its patrons. One reviewer described the café as a “nice coffee place with food,” appreciating the vegetarian options and deeming the Fuel Jacket “a little spicy.”

    Another reviewer raved about the “calming ambience” and “comfortable seating options,” while a third proclaimed that Fuel West serves “the best hot chocolate on campus.” They also highlighted the “reasonable if not slightly higher price” that’s “totally worth it.”

    From its chill atmosphere to its wide variety of food and drinks, Fuel West has carved a niche for itself as a beloved spot for both locals and university students. The only minor drawback, as one reviewer mentioned, is the lack of parking. But if you’re already on campus or don’t mind walking a bit, Fuel West is a must-visit destination for a caffeine kick and a delicious bite to eat.

    Summary review: Java Jo’z in Lafayette, IN

    Imagine finding a cozy corner in a bustling town, a place where coffee is brewed to perfection and served with a side of warm smiles. Java Jo’z in Lafayette, IN, is just that, a safe haven for those in search of a rich cup of coffee.

    Like a treasure trove of caffeine delights, Java Jo’z offers an extensive menu of flavors, enough to make your head spin like a roulette wheel at a casino. Their friendly staff ensures that you feel right at home while your taste buds are taken on a wild ride.

    To order your favorite java fix from Java Jo’z, visit Java Jo’z. Customer favorites include their orange mocha and the mysterious offerings from their “secret” menu.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Java Jo’z in Lafayette, IN

    Java Jo’z in Lafayette is a coffee lover’s paradise, as the reviews paint a picture of a delightful oasis with friendly employees and a wide variety of flavors. One reviewer even goes as far as to mention their “nice rewards card” and highly recommends stopping by for a quick caffeine fix.

    Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, one patron warns of blacked-out prices and a lack of ingredients for certain menu options. This lone dissenter, however, is drowned out by the chorus of praise that sings the virtues of Java Jo’z.

    With an average rating of 4.2, it’s clear that Java Jo’z has found the secret recipe for success, blending great coffee, friendly service, and a charming atmosphere into a perfect cup. So, why not stop by and experience it for yourself?

    Summary review: Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette in Lafayette, IN

    Ah, the smell of freshly roasted coffee beans, the clatter of cups, and the sound of laughter – Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette in Lafayette, IN is like a steaming cup of comfort in a cold, indifferent world.

    With its whimsical atmosphere and lovingly crafted menu, Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. is a warm hug in the form of a coffee shop. And the best part? You can bring that hug home with you by ordering online at Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette. If you’re looking for recommendations, their Americano is a popular choice, as are their savory crepes.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette in Lafayette, IN

    Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette is a cornucopia of delights, with reviews painting a picture of a cozy coffee shop that’s like a caffeine-infused secret garden. One reviewer raves about the “great vibes” and the “absolutely amazing” breakfast crepes, while another applauds the “exact coffee shop vibe” and the “cute coffee shop ambience.”

    Their menu is a masterpiece, with a symphony of flavors that enchant the taste buds. The creme brûlée, cinnamon roll, and sundrenched veggie crepe are all highly recommended by their devoted patrons. Coffee lovers also sing praises for the “delicious” coffee, “fun and tasty” lattes, and the “perfect” espresso drinks.

    With an average rating of 5, Greyhouse Coffee & Supply Co. – West Lafayette is a coffee lover’s paradise. If you find yourself in Lafayette, IN, be sure to stop by and savor the experience for yourself.

    Summary review: Star City Coffee in Lafayette, IN

    In the bustling streets of Lafayette, IN, there’s a quaint little cafe that has managed to capture the hearts of coffee lovers and passersby alike. Nestled amidst the urban landscape, Star City Coffee is the caffeine oasis you never knew you needed. It’s like discovering a hidden treasure in the middle of a bustling city.

    From the moment you step inside, the warm and inviting atmosphere greets you like a long-lost friend. With a rotating selection of seasonal drinks, friendly baristas, and cozy outdoor seating, this little gem is the perfect place to enjoy your cup of joe while taking in the sights and sounds of downtown Lafayette.

    To order your favorite roast from Star City Coffee, visit their website at Star City Coffee. Their espresso blend is a local favorite, perfect for a cortado, while their chai latte and vanilla latte never disappoint.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Star City Coffee in Lafayette, IN

    As one reviewer eloquently states, “The espresso blend here is still my favorite in Lafayette for a regular cortado. Good vibes, great space, and friendly baristas. I’m not sure what else people want in a coffee shoppe.” With an average rating of 4.6, it’s clear that Star City Coffee has struck a chord with its patrons.

    A common thread among the reviews is the mention of their seasonal menu, which adds a delightful element of surprise for those seeking new and exciting flavors. One reviewer shares, “My favorite thing about this cafe is the seasonal rotating drinks they do. I love trying new and different things and am rarely disappointed.”

    The outdoor seating area also receives high praise, providing a comfortable space to enjoy a hot beverage and get some work done on a sunny day. Another reviewer emphasizes the staff’s kindness, adding that Star City Coffee is “Super cute coffee shop with kind staff, clean bathrooms, and a great seasonal menu! The perfect place to spend my 20-minute Greyhound break!”

    Overall, Star City Coffee is a must-visit destination for those in Lafayette, IN, seeking a great cup of coffee, a friendly atmosphere, and a variety of delicious offerings to satisfy their caffeine cravings.

    Wrapped in a dreamlike haze, the enigmatic coffee aficionado, Justin, roams the labyrinthine alleyways of the caffeinated world. Amidst the swirling darkness and flickering neon signs, he seeks the elusive, transcendent flavors that lie hidden in the shadowy corners of the coffee bean's soul.