Get our FREE coffee cheat sheet and get your coffee brew perfect every time.
When you sign up to our newsletter

    By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from Above Average Coffee. We'll respect your privacy and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA

    by Justin | Last Updated: May 11, 2023

    This site participates in various affiliate programs including Amazon’s. Purchases made via our links may result in commission at no additional cost to you.

    Image description

    Discover the best Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA with our comprehensive guide.

    A Local Connoisseur’s Guide to the Top Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA

    RankingCoffee Roaster NameRating
    1Coronation Café5
    2Cushman Market & Cafe4.6
    3Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters4.6
    4Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting4.6
    5Share Coffee Amherst4.5
    6Amherst Coffee + Bar4.5
    7LimeRed Teahouse4.4
    8The Works Café4.3
    9The Black Sheep4.3

    In order to provide comprehensive reviews, we have thoroughly analyzed data from the roasters’ website, articles, and social media posts. Further, we can aggregated and summarized, using quote snippets, left by actual customers of the roaster.  Finally, we have included resource reference links to those reviews in a location map if you are looking for more complete information.  We hope you find this valuable in your search for the best coffee roasters in your area.

    Summary review: Coronation Café in Amherst, MA

    Stepping into Coronation Café is like being transported to an idyllic coffee haven, a place where the beans are as lovingly roasted as a father flipping burgers on a sunny weekend. The staff welcomes you with the warmth of a favorite aunt’s embrace, and the atmosphere exudes a sense of comfort akin to slipping into your favorite pajamas.

    Nestled in the heart of Amherst, this enchanting coffee roastery is a hidden gem, waiting to be discovered by caffeine aficionados and casual coffee drinkers alike. Its rustic charm, paired with an extensive selection of delectable coffee concoctions, sets the stage for an unforgettable experience.

    Their customer favorites include the alluring Cocoa Dusted Mint Latte and the enticing Veggie Pesto Omelet. But don’t let these fan-favorite menu items distract you from the star of the show: their meticulously roasted coffee beans. To order from this coffee paradise, simply visit Coronation Café.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Coronation Café in Amherst, MA

    Coronation Café’s reviews are like a chorus of angels singing the praises of a celestial coffee kingdom. One reviewer lauds the peaceful vibe and lovely background music, while another sings of the fresh, locally sourced ingredients in their Veggie Pesto Omelet.

    The Cocoa Dusted Mint Latte is deemed “amazing” by a satisfied patron, while another raves about the delicious homemade pretzel with salt. The chipotle bacon and egg breakfast sandwich garners high praise, with one fan declaring it a “must-try.”

    The ambiance also garners accolades, as one reviewer describes the warm and rich colors inside, making it a cozy haven for coffee lovers. Quick and friendly service, a good atmosphere, and a plethora of coffee and tea options leave patrons eager to return for another round of java delights.

    With a stellar 5-star average rating, it’s clear that Coronation Café has made its mark on the Amherst coffee scene. The only question that remains is, when will you pay a visit to this delightful coffee oasis?

    Summary review: Cushman Market & Cafe in Amherst, MA

    Cushman Market & Cafe is a hidden treasure trove in Amherst, MA that entices coffee enthusiasts, food lovers, and antique aficionados alike. It’s a quirky fusion of a coffee shop, general store, and a whimsical wonderland of antiques that make you feel as if you’ve stepped into a time capsule.

    The cafe itself is a cozy space, adorned with an eclectic mix of charming knick-knacks and fascinating photographs on the walls. Here, you can enjoy a deliciously crafted coffee along with an array of tasty vegan options. The market section is stocked with healthy provisions and unique gifts that you can take home as souvenirs.

    Experience the delightful charm of Cushman Market & Cafe by visiting their website and ordering your favorite roasts: Cushman Market & Cafe. Customers rave about the matcha latte with soy and the vegan breakfast burrito with added vegan bacon.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Cushman Market & Cafe in Amherst, MA

    Cushman Market & Cafe has garnered a loyal following, with reviewers swooning over the enchanting atmosphere, fantastic vegan options, and friendly staff. One visitor likened the experience to “a hippie Cracker Barrel,” praising the clean restrooms and cozy dining setting.

    Another reviewer appreciated the “great spot to grab a sandwich and a coffee” despite the wait during peak hours, highlighting the accommodating nature of the staff. The selection of organic foods, wines, and beverages, as well as the “amazing fresh made selections” at the cafe, have also earned praise.

    With an impressive 5-star average rating, it’s clear that Cushman Market & Cafe is a beloved gem in Amherst. Whether you’re sipping on a warm cup of coffee, indulging in a scrumptious vegan meal, or perusing the quirky general store, you’re sure to be enchanted by this quirky haven.

    Summary review: Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA

    Have you ever experienced the peculiar joy of finding a coffee shop that feels like a hidden treasure? That’s the sensation you get when you walk into Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA. This coffee haven, nestled in the heart of the college town, offers a delectable assortment of coffee roasts, baked goods, and sandwiches, making it the perfect spot for caffeine enthusiasts and food lovers alike.

    As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere that only a local coffee shop can provide. Whether you’re seeking a quiet spot for some much-needed solace, or a lively hub to meet up with friends, Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters has got you covered. To order your favorite roasts, simply head over to Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters.

    Their customer favorites include the Northampton Veggie sandwich and the Spiced Maple Latte. However, don’t let that limit your exploration. Take your taste buds on an adventure by trying out some of their other offerings, like the Cheese Danish or the Greenfield Sandwich.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters in Amherst, MA

    Ah, the reviews. A mixed bag of beans, ranging from the ecstatic to the confounded. One thing is clear: this coffee shop has left an indelible impression on its patrons. The Cheese Danish, for example, has garnered a five-star review from a customer who sings its praises, declaring it to be the perfect accompaniment to a cup of coffee.

    However, not every experience has been as delightful. One reviewer recounts a less-than-satisfactory encounter, where their Greenfield Sandwich was a far cry from what they had ordered. While this particular instance may have soured the customer’s morning, other reviewers have been more forgiving, acknowledging that the shop sometimes experiences staff turnover and struggles, but ultimately pulls through with excellent bakery items and sandwiches.

    Despite these hiccups, the overall atmosphere and charm of the place have won over many hearts. One reviewer vividly describes their visit as a delightful escape from reality, complete with a mysterious, possibly haunted, bathroom hidden behind a tapestry.

    In the end, Shelburne Falls Coffee Roasters has an overall rating of 3.6 stars. While there may be some inconsistencies in service, the general consensus is that the cozy ambiance, delectable coffee, and scrumptious food make it a worthwhile visit.

    Summary review: Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting in Amherst, MA

    In Amherst, MA, the coffee scene is as vibrant as a kaleidoscope, with Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting providing a colorful addition to the mix. This cozy café, nestled among the greenery, has a secret recipe for coffee that would make even the most jaded coffee enthusiast swoon.

    With a diverse menu that includes brunch options, specialty teas, beers, hard ciders, and wines, Esselon Café caters to a variety of tastes. However, it’s their coffee that shines brightest, like a lighthouse guiding caffeine-seekers through stormy waters.

    Ordering from Esselon Café is as smooth as the foam on their lattes: Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting. Among the customer favorites, you’ll find the Irish malt cold brew and the delightfully earthy beet root latte.

    If Esselon Café were a painting, it would be an impressionist masterpiece, with each brushstroke capturing the essence of a perfect cup of coffee.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting in Amherst, MA

    The reviews for Esselon Café paint a picture as vivid as a Van Gogh, with customers singing praises for the ambiance, food, and drinks. One reviewer, who enjoyed the lox eggs benedict and an array of teas, refers to the café as a “cool hidden gem.” Others rave about the delicious coffee and garden seating, making it the ideal spot for a leisurely visit or a focused work session.

    As the reviews flow together, like a symphony of contentment, a few common themes emerge: friendly staff, a quaint atmosphere, and the unique menu offerings that keep customers coming back for more. With an average rating of 4.6, Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting has carved out a niche in the hearts of Amherst’s coffee aficionados.

    The charm of Esselon Café is perhaps best captured by a reviewer who gushes about their “fantastic beet root latte” and looks forward to returning for more. With such glowing reviews, it’s clear that Esselon Café and Coffee Roasting is a must-visit destination for any coffee lover in Amherst, MA.

    Summary review: Share Coffee Amherst in Amherst, MA

    Like the first rays of sunshine after a long winter, Share Coffee Amherst brings warmth and brightness to the coffee scene in Amherst, MA. The name itself is a testament to their mission: sharing the love and passion for quality coffee with the local community. So, without further ado, let us dive into this delightful treasure trove of delicious coffee and heartwarming atmosphere.

    Share Coffee Amherst, a modern haven for coffee enthusiasts, offers a comfortable and welcoming space where you can savor their artisanal brews. To order and experience the magic for yourself, simply visit: Share Coffee Amherst. If you’re wondering about customer favorites, look no further than their single-origin roasts and the ever-popular seasonal blend.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Share Coffee Amherst in Amherst, MA

    The sweet, caffeinated melody of Share Coffee Amherst seems to have struck a chord with the coffee-drinking public. A symphony of positive reviews creates an undeniable buzz, with one reviewer describing the atmosphere as “delicious” and another praising the “beautiful” interior.

    With an average rating of 4.6, Share Coffee Amherst has certainly made its mark on the hearts of Amherst’s coffee lovers. One reviewer points out that the “friendly baristas” and “great atmosphere” make for a pleasant experience, while another highlights the “welcoming and friendly” staff and “wonderful selection” of both coffees and pastries.

    A third reviewer shares their appreciation for the “bright, cheery place,” noting the spacious interior and outdoor table options. Another customer takes the time to applaud the “perfect beverages,” “healthy foods,” and “comfortable seating” both inside and out, and even goes as far as to mention the “spotless modern decor” and “sparkling team members.”

    Lastly, a fifth reviewer commends the well-made coffee, good latte art, and authentic hot sandwiches, which they note are perfect for when you’re in a hurry. The price, they add, is “acceptable.”

    In summary, Share Coffee Amherst has proven to be a delightful addition to the Amherst coffee scene, offering top-notch coffee, delicious food options, and a cozy atmosphere that appeals to a wide range of patrons. So, grab a cup of their finest roast and let the caffeinated symphony play on.

    Summary review: Amherst Coffee + Bar in Amherst, MA

    When it comes to coffee, a true connoisseur knows the importance of variety, and the town of Amherst, MA doesn’t disappoint. Enter Amherst Coffee + Bar, a charming establishment that is as much a coffee haven as it is a whiskey bar. This combination is perfect for those who appreciate the finer things in life, such as a well-crafted espresso and a fine whiskey to cap off the evening.

    Located in the heart of Amherst, Amherst Coffee + Bar offers a cozy space to enjoy high-quality coffee and a stellar whiskey bar to build camaraderie in the later hours. For those eager to sample their offerings, ordering is made easy by visiting their website: Amherst Coffee + Bar. The customer favorites include a rich, smooth cappuccino with perfectly foamed milk and the delicate pour-over coffee that allows the beans’ true flavors to shine.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for Amherst Coffee + Bar in Amherst, MA

    Amherst Coffee + Bar has an impressive rating, with customers raving about their experiences. One reviewer describes it as “without a doubt the coziest place in Amherst,” where “the coffee is delicious, the staff is friendly, and the whiskey bar which opens at the end of the day was a great source of camaraderie in my grad school years.” Another reviewer commends the “friendly staff” and the unique experience of enjoying “coffee and drinks at the same time.”

    The ambiance seems to be a key factor in customer satisfaction, with reviewers noting the “quiet, low light atmosphere” where people can “sit and enjoy your brew in relative quiet.” Amherst Coffee + Bar also excels in service, as one reviewer highlights the “comprehensive menu” and how “the baristas explain it very well.” Another reviewer was “pleasantly surprised” by the quality of the cocktails and the “bright airy atmosphere” that provides an excellent environment for both work and leisure.

    With an array of positive reviews, it’s clear that Amherst Coffee + Bar is a must-visit destination for coffee lovers in Amherst, MA. The combination of delicious coffee, cozy ambiance, and friendly staff make it an unforgettable experience for all who visit.

    Summary review: LimeRed Teahouse in Amherst, MA

    If you’re a bubble tea enthusiast wandering the streets of Amherst, MA, prepare to be dazzled by LimeRed Teahouse. This delightful spot offers an impressive array of bubble tea concoctions, artfully crafted to quench your thirst and satisfy your taste buds.

    Upon entering LimeRed Teahouse, you’ll be greeted by the vibrant decor and warm, welcoming atmosphere. What truly sets this place apart, however, is their extensive menu, offering a delightful assortment of teas, smoothies, juices, and even coffee for those who can’t resist a good brew.

    Ready to order your next favorite bubble tea? Don’t hesitate to visit LimeRed Teahouse. Customer favorites include the unique blend of Matcha latte with soy milk and boba, and an ever-changing selection of delightful macaron flavors.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for LimeRed Teahouse in Amherst, MA

    At LimeRed Teahouse, it’s not just the bubble tea that leaves a lasting impression. The reviewers’ shared experiences paint a picture of a bustling, cheerful spot where students congregate and customers appreciate the fantastic service.

    One reviewer praises the establishment for offering a great selection of quality teas and fruit juices, as well as the efficiency of the staff. They note that LimeRed can get quite busy during peak hours, but the lines move swiftly thanks to the attentive staff.

    Another reviewer admires the updated menu options, such as the inclusion of dairy alternatives like soy and oat milk and adjustable sweetness levels. The packaging and decor also receive rave reviews.

    The freshness of the pearls and the vast variety of flavors available at LimeRed Teahouse also leave customers delighted. One regular patron admits to enjoying trying random flavors, while their spouse sticks to more traditional choices.

    Finally, a customer who appreciates sweet treats lauds LimeRed for their refreshing and visually appealing drinks. They also mention the convenience of online ordering and delivery, which makes it even easier to enjoy LimeRed Teahouse’s offerings.

    With a consistent string of positive reviews, LimeRed Teahouse has undoubtedly cemented its position as a must-visit destination for bubble tea enthusiasts in Amherst, MA.

    Summary review: The Works Café in Amherst, MA

    The Works Café in Amherst, MA, is a place where good food, great coffee, and a warm atmosphere come together to create a symphony of flavors and experiences for its patrons. Like a well-executed dance routine, The Works Café has managed to strike the perfect balance between a cozy coffee shop and a bustling eatery, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

    With an ever-changing menu of house-roasted coffee, delicious sandwiches, and mouth-watering burritos, this delightful café caters to every palate. To order their amazing coffee, simply visit: The Works Café. The Works Café’s chai is a crowd favorite, along with their varied and fresh sandwiches.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for The Works Café in Amherst, MA

    The Works Café has captured the hearts and taste buds of many, with reviewers singing its praises like a choir of coffee-loving angels. One reviewer, enamored with their first chai experience, describes it as “delicious” and gives the café a rare 5-star rating. They also mention their friends’ satisfaction with the “beautiful sandwiches/burritos.”

    Another customer highlights the excellent customer service, with the manager going “above and beyond” to rectify a small issue with their order. They assert that the chai at The Works Café is “the best in town.” However, not everyone was entirely pleased with their experience; a reviewer found their latte to be of “poor quality” and was disappointed with the service on one occasion.

    On the food front, the café has been praised for offering a range of organic and healthy options, such as organic farm bread and a scrumptious salmon bagel. One reviewer, who visited five years ago, noted that The Works Café is an ideal place for students and people looking to relax or study while sipping on a cup of coffee or tea.

    Unfortunately, there is one customer who felt they experienced age discrimination at the café. Despite this, the overall sentiment towards The Works Café is overwhelmingly positive, with the food, coffee, and atmosphere making it a popular choice in Amherst, MA.

    Summary review: The Black Sheep in Amherst, MA

    A college town like Amherst, MA, is the perfect setting for a quaint, unassuming coffee roaster like The Black Sheep. And much like the endearing misfit it’s named after, this delightful spot is sure to charm the caffeine-addicted and famished alike. With its cozy atmosphere and mouthwatering menu, The Black Sheep feels like a warm embrace on a chilly New England day.

    Whether you’re searching for a velvety cappuccino or a hearty sandwich, The Black Sheep has it all. Ordering is as easy as waltzing through the door and pointing at the menu: The Black Sheep. Customer favorites include their chocolate croissants and the ever-popular Fowl Play sandwich.

    Our Take: Summarized Reviews for The Black Sheep in Amherst, MA

    Picture this: a coffee shop and café so endearing that even the most scathing of critics would find it hard not to feel a soft spot for it. The Black Sheep’s reviews are a mixed bag, like a group of college friends with vastly different majors, all gathered for a stimulating debate.

    Some reviewers sing the praises of the scrumptious food and cozy atmosphere, one even describing it as “family approved.” Yet, others lament the high prices and underfilled sandwiches. One reviewer, reminiscing about the good old days of The Black Sheep, mournfully recalls how the once-tasty bread has lost its flavor.

    Despite its ups and downs, The Black Sheep remains a beloved institution in Amherst, MA. With an average rating of 3 stars, it’s a place that may not be at the top of everyone’s list, but it’s surely one to visit when you’re in town, looking for a warm cup of coffee and a tasty bite.

    Wrapped in a dreamlike haze, the enigmatic coffee aficionado, Justin, roams the labyrinthine alleyways of the caffeinated world. Amidst the swirling darkness and flickering neon signs, he seeks the elusive, transcendent flavors that lie hidden in the shadowy corners of the coffee bean's soul.